Over It: Why We Dumped Instagram


Today, we said “goodbye” to Instagram. While we’ve enjoyed (virtually) meeting great people in many countries, we struggled with a fundamental conflict that we cannot, personally, satisfactorily resolve: how to be part of social media without sacrificing the privacy of our personal information to the whims of a company that answers to one master – its shareholders.

Facebook, Inc. is a business (as are the other entities it’s assimilated, including Instagram), and its provision of this platform isn’t driven by altruism: despite the appearance that it’s free, there is a cost to using Instagram. That cost to users is allowing Facebook, Inc. to use users’ personal information for a number of purposes, including those that fall under “research”. That may sound relatively innocuous, but it’s not: for example, how would you feel about not having access to certain features that you know other users do? Without knowing why? On its face, it sounds discriminatory…and practically speaking, it’s just annoying.

We encountered this exact situation during our very brief foray into the Facebook world: we each created accounts and I discovered that I was unable to see the Marketplace, one of the primary reasons we created a Facebook account – but Patrick could access it on his account. As a rule, we take exception to being participants in “social experiments” without first providing our express, informed consent. We quickly realized how little value Facebook brought to us, so we closed our accounts and never looked back. Sadly, we’ve recently noticed more and more Facebook-like activity occurring on Instagram.

We hope that all Instagram users will read the updated Terms and Data Policy that was pushed out at roughly midnight Eastern time last night and understand what it means – how it permits Facebook, Inc. to use your information, and how it affects your rights (like the Arbitration provision). If you’re in the U.S. – like us – read it very carefully, as we are afforded fewer protections than our EU friends. We’ve read it and have decided that it’s just not worth it, and have exercised the option to simply delete our account. (And if you decide you want to try to delete your photos before you close your account, Instagram will play games to try to thwart you…after a certain number of deletes, it simply stopped deleting the photos and displayed the message to “try again later” – doubtless, hoping you’ll just give up in frustration!)

Ever heard of Facebook Pixel? You can find more information about this “invisible code that’s dropped onto the other websites that allows that site and Facebook to track users’ activity” in the New York Times article here: Facebook Privacy Hearings. You’ll probably be, at the very least, perturbed.

Maybe social media’s scope creep regarding users’ personal information bothers us more than the average social media user because of our frames of reference; what we consider to be unduly invasive and manipulative may seem acceptable to others. We sincerely hope not.

If you’re reading this blog post, we’re glad you found us and we want you to know that we’ll continue posting fresh content on farm happenings, clean food, and ferments here. Sign up below to receive notifications of new posts!

7 thoughts on “Over It: Why We Dumped Instagram

  1. Oh, dear. Now I have to think hard about if I want to continue on Instagram. But we survived before Instagram, didn’t we? Perhaps it is a gift to be forced back to a more conscious and thoughtful way of interacting on the web.

    I went looking for your hatchling photos to show a 7-year-old friend last night, and panicked … but I’m ever so grateful you’re still here.

  2. I am sad to read that you’ve left, but honestly I do not blame you! I didn’t know IG was owned by FB until recently and just a couple days ago started having issues with uploading posts. I am literally stuck doing nothing for THREE days of looking at my account and I cannot do anything. I cannot even switch to my personal account bc it’s “stuck” and I haven’t been seeing all the accounts I follow. My FB page hardly gets views bc I won’t sponsor anything. So I have been thinking about what I really want out of these accounts. I really loved your content. I will try to stay up to speed with your blogs. Thanks for sharing this. It was really informative and I appreciate your input!

  3. I hate that you left IG. You were one of my favorite accounts. But I totally understand why you left. I’ll look forward to you’re blogs

    1. I wish we did have a better place to follow other like minded people and accounts.

Comments are closed.